Excise taxes and policy incoherence in New Zealand
Ok, I’m coming permanently out of “proper blogging” retirement. Why?
The New Zealand government has decided to cut fuel taxes and RUC due to the “cost of living crisis” in New Zealand – egged on by the opposition and a range of New Zealand thinktanks and “thought leaders”. When a similar spike occurred in 2008 such a suggestion would have been ridiculed for being the ill thought out and incoherent policy it is – now it is the sort of stuff that gets a cross-party consensus and loud repeated cheers from the tens of New Zealand Twitterazzi.
Honestly, what is wrong with policy debate in New Zealand – when did we go from caring about policy outcomes and trade-offs to treating every policy decision as something that must be done urgently as if we are in the middle of an episode of West Wing. I mean, read the analysis in the two front-page articles on Stuff (here and here) – it is all politics and no consideration of trade-offs.
Want to understand why I see things this way – click the tab and read on.
Read more